
Roxy Hotel New York
Best for live music, nightlife and guests who want a downtown boutique with on-site entertainment.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Roxy Hotel New York is a creative, entertainment-driven boutique on the SoHo/Tribeca border for travelers who want nightlife, live jazz and downtown character. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a prestigious 5-star Midtown property for luxury travelers who want classic service, Central Park access and formal event spaces.
Updated · about 3.8 km apart

Best for live music, nightlife and guests who want a downtown boutique with on-site entertainment.

Best for travelers seeking a classic 5-star Midtown address, formal meeting/balance-of-service and Central Park access.
When Roxy Hotel New York wins: choose Roxy if you want a downtown, food-and-music-focused stay with a lively bar, a subterranean jazz club (The Django), an art-house cinema and on-site event spaces for informal or entertainment-led gatherings. It’s the better pick for nightlife, creative events and strong pet-friendly policies.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: choose Four Seasons for traditional 5-star Midtown luxury, larger suites (including Central Park and Manhattan suites), formal meeting and banquet facilities, limousine service options and a quieter, prestige-focused atmosphere near 57th Street and 5th Avenue.
Bottom line: Roxy is a characterful, entertainment-forward boutique for downtown experiences and social nights out; Four Seasons is the choice for established 5-star service, larger suites and a Midtown location close to Central Park and Fifth Avenue. Pick based on whether you want downtown energy or Midtown formality.
| Category | Roxy Hotel New York | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Creative, entertainment-driven boutique with nightlife and arts focus | Formal 5-star Midtown luxury, service- and event-oriented |
| Location | SoHo/Tribeca border (2 Avenue of the Americas) — downtown Manhattan | Midtown Manhattan (57 E 57th Street) — near Fifth Avenue and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 201 rooms | 368 guestrooms (individually decorated) |
| Minimum check-in age | 21 (valid ID and card required) | 18 (per supplier listing) |
| Pools | No swimming pool on site (has a 9-foot billiards table) | Indoor pool (hotel widely known to have a pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | Roxy Bar, The Django (jazz), The Oyster Bar, Roxy Café — active nightlife/dining mix | The Garden Restaurant, bar/lounge and 24-hour room service; cooked-to-order breakfasts available (surcharge) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa (hair/beauty salon only); partnership with nearby Aire Ancient Baths | Full-service spa and wellness facilities (spa and treatments available) |
| Known for | Live entertainment, jazz club, cinema, rooftop terrace and event spaces | Prestige, large suites (Central Park/Manhattan suites), conference/banquet facilities and limo service |
| Event & meeting space | About 12,396 sq ft across multiple venues including an 8-story atrium (Roxy Bar) and a 118-seat cinema | Conference center and ~12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²) of meeting space including ballroom and meeting rooms |
| Pet policy | Exceptionally pet-friendly; no pet fees, provides bowls and bedding | Pets may be arranged by contacting property (supplier listing notes guests can arrange to bring pets) |
Roxy sits on the SoHo–TriBeCa boundary, convenient for downtown shopping, dining and the Brooklyn Bridge.
Choose Roxy for downtown access, neighborhood character and easy bike or subway trips around lower Manhattan.
Four Seasons is on East 57th Street near Fifth Avenue and Central Park, putting you in Midtown’s high-end corridor.
Choose Four Seasons for Midtown convenience, museum and shopping access and a quieter, central Manhattan base.
Roxy offers a compact set of creative room types and suites reflecting its boutique personality.
Roxy’s rooms are boutique-focused and practical, with in-room minibars and strong connectivity options.
Four Seasons lists a wide range of individually decorated rooms and larger signature suites.
Four Seasons specializes in larger, individually styled rooms and multiple suite choices, including Central Park views.
Roxy’s food-and-music program centers on several on-site venues that run late into the evening.
Pick Roxy if you want integrated nightlife, live jazz and a multi-venue, late-night dining scene.
Four Seasons follows a classic luxury-hotel dining model with formal restaurant and bar service.
Choose Four Seasons for formal dining, room service and quieter restaurant service aligned with 5-star expectations.
Roxy emphasizes on-site entertainment rather than pool or full spa facilities.
If live entertainment, cinema and jazz matter more than a pool or spa, Roxy fits better.
Four Seasons focuses on full-service luxury amenities and wellness offerings.
If a full-service spa, indoor pool and formal event facilities are priorities, Four Seasons is the stronger match.
Roxy provides a 24-hour fitness center and extensive nightly entertainment options.
Roxy combines round-the-clock exercise options with a dominant nightlife program.
Four Seasons offers fitness facilities alongside quieter guest services and evening dining.
Four Seasons emphasizes wellness, service and calm evenings rather than on-site nightlife.

Roxy — on-site jazz club (The Django), Roxy Bar performances and DJs make it the better pick for nightlife.

Four Seasons — established 5-star service, larger suites (Central Park and Manhattan suites) and formal event spaces.

Roxy — exceptionally pet-friendly with no pet fees, in-room pet amenities and access to a sister-property dog park.

Four Seasons — large conference/ballroom options, dedicated meeting space and limo/town car service.
Roxy Hotel New York — it runs live jazz nightly at The Django plus DJs and late-night programming at Roxy Bar.
Four Seasons Hotel New York — it’s located on East 57th Street near Fifth Avenue and Central Park.
Roxy does not have an on-site swimming pool or full spa; it does have an on-site hair/beauty salon and partners with nearby Aire Ancient Baths for spa services.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is family-friendly per the supplier listing (it notes one child 17 or younger stays free with an adult); it is not listed as adults-only.
Explore how Roxy Hotel New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·